Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Lola_PopBBae t1_j34pjdn wrote

This is hilariously depressing.

Man nearly dies for a stupid, violent, unsafe game- and that's the first thought.

−29

reddit455 OP t1_j35fyqe wrote

is able to USE WORDS.
short term memory intact.

remembers he's a football player.

​

encouraging, from a "no brain damage due to lack of oxygen" perspective.

​

literally the BEST thing he could say.

78

CO_PC_Parts t1_j35kq08 wrote

And there’s a good chance he doesn’t remember anything after the tackle.

15

Lola_PopBBae t1_j35h09n wrote

Alright, that's fair!

I still think we should seriously re-evaluate the sport from the ground up, and how much damage it can and does do to humans.

12

xdrakennx t1_j36oi0b wrote

The NFL has been around in some form or another since 1920. Between then and now, this is the first incident of impact induced cardia arrest has happened on the field. That alone should tell you how rare this is. This requires millisecond precise timing.

2

cocainesupernova t1_j34y6qh wrote

there's nothing wrong with loving something dangerous as long as you love it and respect it. not everything needs to be the safest thing in the world, and neither can some things be the safest thing in the world. this was a freak injury, not something that's likely to happen in the sport for another hundred years. it happens rarely in every sport at every level.

19

reidlos1624 t1_j35cc3x wrote

Yeah, pretty much any sport is dangerous. Can't count how many times I almost died or mangled myself skiing or on ATVs. Wouldn't have stopped me though.

5

Jealous-Elephant t1_j35dtsy wrote

Minimizes all the other extreme damage playing football does

2

reddit455 OP t1_j35hn0n wrote

if this is what happened.. it's not the game, it's (extremely) bad timing. if it was more common there'd be dead kids all over the country. one NFL player on national TV might just prevent more from happening in the future.

​

188 kids about 15 y/o "and fewer than one in five survived the incident."

​

you need a chest pad for football and baseball and polo, and rugby, and cricket, and hurling....baseball is not violent. but a pitcher taking a come backer could drop dead if the ball hits the wrong spot at the right time.

​

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commotio_cordis

Commotio cordis (Latin, "agitation or disruption of the heart") is a rare lethal disruption of heart rhythm that occurs as a result of a blow to the area directly over the heart (the precordial region) at a critical time during the cycle of a heartbeat.[1] This leads to disrupting normal heart electrical activity, followed instantly by ventricular fibrillation, complete disorganization of the heart's pumping function, and cardiac arrest. It is not caused by mechanical damage to the heart muscle or surrounding organs and is not the result of heart disease.

​

Some of the sports which have a risk for this cause of trauma are baseball, American football, association football (soccer), ice hockey, polo, rugby football, cricket, softball, pelota, lacrosse, boxing, professional wrestling, hurling and martial arts (see Touch of Death). Children are especially vulnerable, possibly due to the mechanical properties of their thoracic skeleton.[1][5] From 1996 to spring 2007, the USA National Commotio Cordis Registry had 188 cases recorded, with about half occurring during organized sports.[6] Almost all (96%) of the victims were male, the mean age of the victims during that period was 14.7 years, and fewer than one in five survived the incident.[6]

1

Jealous-Elephant t1_j35i20x wrote

Bro... only in this context would this happen but again like it’s not just deaths on the field which are rare yes but like football is incredibly harmful and has lead to many many deaths and deaths of despair. Your argument doesn’t address the issue it just takes a very narrow slice

1

aslightlyusedtissue t1_j37i4f9 wrote

In what way is that minimizing? Like seriously. Read it again.

He’s saying he believes that it isnt wrong to love and respect something dangerous. And that we as a people shouldn’t just get rid of or change every dangerous thing. The NFL and the people who play it are very aware of the dangers of the game, are trying with every passing season to make the game safer, and most importantly they CHOOSE to play this game. The people playing the game now had access to way more technology and information regarding the effects and dangers of football than the players from the 80s and further back. They know more than anyone how dangerous it is, which is good. Because they know better than anyone how to minimize the damage caused by the game they love.

No one. And i mean NO ONE. Is downplaying how dangerous football is. Strawman argument.

1

Lola_PopBBae t1_j35hatj wrote

I mean, yes- there IS something wrong with loving dangerous things. Even if it doesn't hurt you, it can and likely will hurt someone else. Concussions, broken bones, and a psychological toll on the players- not to mention how it trains young boys to solve every problem with violence.
Just to name a few.

Freak injury it may have been, but there's plenty of others that happen in this ridiculous sport that America worships.

−11

EddieCheddar88 t1_j35oz8b wrote

We get it, you hate sports

5

Lola_PopBBae t1_j35ygzt wrote

Bingo!

−3

EddieCheddar88 t1_j35yyfg wrote

Makes sense, only people that suck at them and couldn’t play them hate on others for enjoying them or being good at them. Judging by your profile, that’s definitely the case lol

1

babypho t1_j35aapk wrote

"You've been asleep for 70 years, Cap."

9

Eliasjr04 t1_j35s1tq wrote

Wait until this person discovers xgames

4

Lola_PopBBae t1_j35yfit wrote

Oh no, I think that's insane too. But football has a long history of lawsuits and problems, and we continue to ignore the dangers for petty entertainment.

−1

jdmcroberts t1_j36njmb wrote

Living is dangerous. I wouldn't go outside today.

1

Lola_PopBBae t1_j38qla5 wrote

I'm a hermit, no problems there.

Risk is everywhere, I get that. But there's a lot we can do to make things better, and the fact we keep sacrificing young men to this dumb game is ridiculous to me.

1