fettuccine_sequence t1_iuufmqd wrote on November 3, 2022 at 2:13 AM

Reply to comment by 2358452 in Germany wants to revive fund to save Amazon rainforest – DW by AsslessBaboon

It is pointless to fund conservation while also partially own a company contributing to the contamination and deforestation process.

> The court accepted, on October 19, to hear the lawsuit filed by the Association of Caboclos, Indigenous and Quilombolas of the Amazon, Cainquiama, and nine other people. The victims are seeking financial compensation for at least 10 large spills of "red mud", a toxic sludge composed of clay, silica and metal leftovers from the refining of bauxite, the ore that gives rise to aluminum. The tailings are dumped by Alunorte and Albrás, Hydro's affiliates and subsidiaries in Brazil. Six of its Rotterdam-based subsidiaries are listed in the case.

> The process in Rotterdam now moves on to the merits phase - that is, the judicial analysis of the request for financial compensation based on the evidence and defense arguments of the parties. The association is represented in the process by the British law firm Pogust Goodhead - the same one that defends those affected by the collapse of the Fundão dam in Mariana - by the Brazilian lawyer Ismael Moraes and by the Dutch law firm Lemstra van der Korst.

> "We have great hope and confidence that the Dutch Justice will finally decide for reparation for these people, who have been suffering for decades. The acceptance of jurisdiction, in itself, already represents a milestone towards justice for those affected, which unfortunately we have not achieved in Brazil," said Moraes.

> According to the lawyer, if there is an award for compensation, the money will be received in an account in the Netherlands and then legally transferred to Brazil.

> Hydro said it "will present its defense following the legal procedures in the Dutch justice". The company "vehemently denies the allegations presented by the plaintiffs" and said that it "is committed to being a good neighbor, acting responsibly and putting health, environment, and safety first wherever it operates.

Translated with www.DeepL.com/Translator (free version)

https://theintercept.com/2022/10/21/norsk-hydro-aluminio-contaminacao-bacarena-para/

2358452 t1_iuuhsxa wrote on November 3, 2022 at 2:29 AM

I also don't like what they seem to be doing, thank you for the link! Hopefully the international courts fully investigate the issues.

But I also think their help is extremely significant, they should not be discouraged of helping even if their home companies are contributing to deforestation. In reality deforestation is an enormous issue distributed across many states and vast lands, involving many industries including wood and cattle ranchers, as well as mining as in this case (which beyond deforestation also poisons communities, illegal gold mining has been a huge source of mercury contamination). I believe in this case we should treat the issues separately, and not criticize them for their donation, but investigate the mining issues very seriously (they seem very grave, including widespread lead contamination).

Hopefully we can get this fixed according to better standards, and also resume foreign contribution to the Amazon that is much welcome and needed!