respaaaaaj t1_j1w2vgm wrote
Reply to comment by lucidlilacdream in Large deposit of rare elements and minerals discovered in northern Maine by CptnAlex
Do you think people in Aroostook county or people in Burundi will suffer more for having a mine opened around them?
lucidlilacdream t1_j1waoep wrote
First of all, for this to even be a fair argument the materials available in Maine and Burundi would have to be exactly the same, which is unlikely.
Second, I am not advocating mining in vulnerable places overseas. There should be less mining, less consumption, and more recycling and reusing of materials rather than ripping up the land in vulnerable communities. Many of mines in the US disproportionately impact Native communities, and poorer communities. It’s not social justice to move the impact from one vulnerable community to another. Where I worked on the air quality project, the air was full of lead and arsenic next to a school. The people being poisoned were children, all of who were low income and and majority Latino. Who profits off this? A few very wealthy people.
What we should be doing is mining less, extending the life of electronics, recycling electronics, and living with less. If you are truly worried about mining overseas, which I kind of doubt you are and assume you are trolling, then advocate for more environmental and human rights protections on a global level as well as more research and methods into recycling of metals. Advocate against corporate greed and over extraction of materials.
respaaaaaj t1_j1wd6md wrote
Reclyling and extending the life of existing materials should be done, and people should support expanding human rights and environmental protections.
But the sad reality is that those things will not take effect in time to matter for people currently suffering under the abuses of the way the global economy is currently shaped
lucidlilacdream t1_j1wey93 wrote
and neither will mining in Maine. Mining in Maine will not stop mining overseas. They’ll just extract from both places for more profit, and harm multiple communities.
The only way to possibly stop it is to actually move to more sustainable practices and by pushing for for environmental rights for people.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments