Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

sskdkn_pl t1_j5r7u9b wrote

Reply to comment by goldemerald in [D] CVPR Reviews are out by banmeyoucoward

I also got this… Anyone with this score got accepted in the past?

3

synonymous1964 t1_j5sz1gg wrote

At ICCV 2021, we got a paper accepted with initial reviews of borderline, borderline, weak reject.

If the reviewers' comments are addressable, and you do so in a good rebuttal, there is a chance for acceptance with a bit of luck.

6

toftinosantolama t1_j5rtegr wrote

I don't have an answer to your question, but given that the reviewers don't know the scores of the rest of the reviewers during the rebuttal, a good rebuttal could raise potentially all of them, but even with 2 borderlines being raised to weak accepts, accept should be possible. Good lucks folks.

2

sskdkn_pl t1_j5rzgtt wrote

Thanks for your reply…! You just brighten my day and give me the courage to response the reviewers… Thanks again!

3

deep_noob t1_j6gab7l wrote

I think during discussion they will know about the other reviews, otherwise there is point of discussion

1