Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

silenac t1_j5q1lu3 wrote

1 borderline, 2 weak rejects. For the first submission, it’s okay. Is there any statistics on changing the recommendations after rebuttal?

5

KrakenInAJar t1_j5q51at wrote

Common wisdom is to not bet on flipping, but it is a case by case thing and it can happen.
Read the reviews and if you can deliver a good, carefully worded rebuttal you may flip one or two. But in the end it depends on how open the reviewers are to flip.

9