Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

curiousshortguy t1_j1s504a wrote

Reply to comment by Iwannabeaviking in [D] Are reviewer blacklists actually implemented at ML conferences? by XalosXandrez

> whilst some conferences are American yes, not all are

The ones OP mentions (ICML / ICLR / NeurIPS) are though.

> Blacklist is a universal term and is not offensive and trying to say so is stupid so changing the language to appease a small minority of people is stupid

There's enoguh science to back up that this is probably not stupid:

> https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6007773/
but of course, if you don't care about a minority because they're a minority, you can go ahead and do whatever you want to do. You just might be an inconsiderate asshat then.

−2

Iwannabeaviking t1_j1s5nxt wrote

of course, it matters to the individual and for the individual to concern themselves with.

The concept of science is the detail within, not the language used as long as the result is shown to be what is proven/unproven.

2