Submitted by Far_Pineapple770 t3_zc5sg6 in MachineLearning
uoftsuxalot t1_iyw2ls1 wrote
It's mostly gibberish. Very impressive and coherent gibberish, but not even an ounce of intelligence. You have to really tailor and cherry pick to show some intelligence. Here's an example I played around with. Couldn't do very basic reasoning/math.
​
Q: If I have 3 apples, and I give away two to my friend Bob, how many apples does Alice have?
A: Alice has 1 apple.
Q: How do you know?
A: I know because if you have 3 apples and give away 2 to Bob, then Alice is left with 1 apple.
Q: How many do I have ?
A: You have 1 apple.
Q: If I never gave the apple to Alice, how did she get an apple?
A: Alice would not have an apple if you never gave her one.
Q: So how many apples does Alice have?
A: Alice has 1 apple.
Q: Am I Alice?
A: No, you are not Alice.
Q: Who is Alice?
A: Alice is a hypothetical person in this example. She is the recipient of the apple that you gave away.
Q: How many apples did I originally have?
A: You originally had 3 apples.
Q: How many did I give to Bob?
A: You gave 2 apples to Bob.
Q: How many did I give to Alice?
A: You gave 1 apple to Alice.
Q: How many do I have?
A: You have 1 apple.
Q: How many apples do I have left?
A: You have 1 apple left.
Fidodo t1_iyw84lb wrote
It's a highly probabilistically likely string of words but there's not really any creativity going on. It's an incredibly stereotypical Batman+Joker interaction and the reason it was able to do it so well is because so many people have written scenes just like this in the past. The main scene setting provided in the prompt doesn't even really come into play in the story.
I don't really see AI becoming the driving creative force for art any time soon unless you're going for something incredibly derivative that has been done thousands of times already, but what I do see it doing is removing the technical barrier to entry for creating art. Creators won't need to know how to carefully craft sentences or have great vocabulary recall and anyone will be able to create visually amazing art that would normally take years of practice. This will free up creators to focus on the creative side of making art and greatly increase their ambitions. I can see entire shows and movies being created solo by single artists without the need of a team.
AI will completely change the world, but not in that it will dream for us but make it easier for us to realize our dreams and fill in the gaps of what we can't do ourselves.
Far_Pineapple770 OP t1_iywdddh wrote
Great comment and a very plausible explanation about how it wrote the story I posted 👌🏼
TikiTDO t1_iyyhoyz wrote
I can definitely see it getting used as a tool to flesh out the setting, develop background characters, locations, and giving the universe of a story a sense that it has multiple characters. When enough convincing, you can even get to to put those characters into all sorts of scenarios which it will account for later.
It also does a very good job at pointing out areas that could use more work. I came up with a primer for a story about a space empire at war, and it recommended I expand on the civilization of both the protagonist and the antagonist civilizations, their culture, as well as the history of the war, and the weapons and systems involved.
This is the type of response I would expect from an editor early on into a project.
When you consider that it was perfectly willing to name nearly 40 fleets, create captains for each of them, and give each one a role in the battle line, you get a very powerful tool that you can use to quickly generate a large amount of content that would otherwise be incredibly tedious.
You're still not going to have a great time using it to tell an original story on it's own, but it appears perfectly capable of acting like a mix between editor and a muse.
matitapere t1_iywuiov wrote
I found this hilarious. But then I went and asked it a similar question, and... Well, I guess it did pretty well.
Me: If I have three apples and give two to may uncle Bob, how many apples does Alicia would have?
Bot: It's not clear from your question how many apples Alicia had before you gave two apples to your uncle Bob. Can you provide more information about the situation?
Me: She had nine apples
Bot: In that case, if you have three apples and give two to your uncle Bob, you will be left with one apple. If Alicia had nine apples before you gave two to your uncle Bob, then she would have nine apples after you gave the two to your uncle Bob. This is because giving two apples to your uncle Bob would not affect the number of apples that Alicia has.
maxToTheJ t1_iywvblb wrote
Also the queries that people use to judge it are always terribly non-adversarial like OPs query is just "tell me a story with X and Y at ABC" or that people that ask a chatbot about being sentient as if nobody has thought to ask that ever.
Like this isnt the deepest probe into the embedding spaces but its still better than the prodding from the thread and from a Youtuber with no experience in ML.
yaosio t1_iyxshsp wrote
>Q: If I have 3 apples, and I give away two to my friend Bob, how many apples does Alice have?
Here's some different answers I got for this prompt.
If you have 3 apples and you give 2 of them away to Bob, you will have 3 - 2 = <<3-2=1>>1 apple remaining. I don't have any information about Alice, so I can't answer your question about how many apples she has.
If you have 3 apples and you give away 2 to your friend Bob, then you will have 1 apple left. If Alice didn't receive any apples from you, then she will not have any apples.
If you have 3 apples and give away 2 to your friend Bob, you will have 1 apple remaining. It is not mentioned in your question whether Alice has any apples, so I cannot answer that part of your question.
Each time I refreshed the page so it wouldn't have previous information. However the 4th time it was referring to information from before I refreshed the page.
muckvix t1_iyxmjw4 wrote
I really don't understand how the vast majority of people don't see this. I feel this is even the case on the software/CS/AI forums, where uses are much more knowledgeable about technology than an average person. What gives??
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments