Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Aswarin t1_iv3cirx wrote

I had one reject (but their comments read as though they just hated the idea/lack of novelty) and three marginally below the accept line. One of my reviewers pulled out but I've got no idea what my score is as it says NA currently. Overall the reject annoyed me just touting its not novel but looking at the comments of the others hopefully I can change some minds.

5

tfburns t1_iv3o2on wrote

At the very least, since the reviews and your replies are public, you can try to correct the record re misconceptions, even if you don't end up changing certain reviewers' minds. And sometimes when replying to one reviewer you can convince a different reviewer. Good luck.

2