Submitted by pumpkinsmasher76 t3_xz8x57 in MachineLearning
I applied to PhD programs this past cycle and was rejected by all. I plan on trying again in a future cycle but was wondering how I can gain experience related to ML/NLP especially given that I have already graduated. My GPA was a ~3.3 and while I do have some research experience (mainly a data science REU in my senior year) I didn't get much exposure to anything ML related until taking a graduate level NLP course in my last semester.
I did some side work with a professor and another project with a couple of postdocs but this was either short term or dropped off as my full time job began to take up more time. Right now I'm still looking to see how I can gain experience in this exciting field while I'm still working. Should I continue to ask professors in nearby universities even though I'm not actively enrolled as a student. Or could I also ask those in my current company (even though they aren't necessarily as involved research-wise)?
jfrankle t1_irlqzoi wrote
(I'm a professor at a major CS program.) Applying to a PhD program is applying to a job. You have to:
In fact, it's applying to more than a job. When I hire researchers at my company, I definitely don't expect them to stay for 5+ years, and I know that I can tell them to leave in the rare/unfortunate circumstance that it's not a good fit. For a PhD applicant, I'm making the commitment to hire you and keep you employed for five years no matter what. That's a really high bar, and it should be if I want both of us to be successful.
And, strangely, despite this significant commitment, the PhD admissions process is often lower-touch than a job interview. I get to see a personal statement and some letters of reference, and I might get to interview you, but certainly not at the level of rigor of an industry job.
Bottom line: from my point of view as a faculty member, PhD admissions is a job application, except the stakes are even higher because the commitment is bigger. If you have a mediocre GPA and a tiny bit of irrelevant research experience, I can see why that doesn't cut it.
So what do you do?
Finally, you should ask yourself whether a PhD is what you want/need. There are plenty of ways to get a PhD's worth of experience in industry research roles without needing to make the sacrifices attendant to a PhD. At least, if you don't want a job (like being a professor) that requires a PhD.