Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

unzercharlie t1_iw0ir1u wrote

I completely understand the sentiment, and I love the idea of someone seeing a loved one in color.

I did a restoration for my grandparents, but I was able to say "what color was that jacket?" and "what color was that dress?" and "what color was that truck?" They loved it and I loved doing it. I googled to find the original colors everywhere I could.

Colorizing something and just guessing the colors, or letting AI guess the colors, is something else entirely. I get doing it to learn colorization, or as a fun experiment, but I still believe it's the equivalent of a coloring book, and ruins a perfectly good black and white photo, which is a more accurate representation of history.

−3

JimJohnes t1_iw1iwp5 wrote

How can you "ruin" digital copy of a photo?

7

u1tralord t1_iw0khhl wrote

Future iterations likely will have those features. This tech is just recently being made available to the public.

For now, you can just re-run it again for another variation

3

brownowski t1_iw0x2b6 wrote

You can add that into the prompt given to the AI already. E.g. a red truck or woman in a yellow dress. Although, I have found you need to find a name for the colour that represents it pretty accurately, otherwise it might add a tint to the entire photo. You might get poor results just saying brown or red instead of burnt sienna or something more specific.

1

blitz672 t1_iw3r92o wrote

So I did some tinkering with the word text and it was a bit better. What's funny is running the same original img Thu a 2nd yielded vastly different results.

Original color

https://imgur.com/z6KsLMJ.jpg

Black and white

https://imgur.com/C7bu2Yq.jpg

1st time Thu

https://imgur.com/j9a39gK.jpg

2nd

https://imgur.com/z6KsLMJ.jpg

Tweeked text prompt

https://imgur.com/C7bu2Yq.jpg

https://imgur.com/EjnZBwf.jpg https://imgur.com/NFTzuT5.jpg

1

enilea t1_iw34pti wrote

>letting AI guess the colors

You can change the text prompt to choose different colors

0