Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

cvaldez74 t1_iwly084 wrote

Hi Gilbert & Kelsey! Are you planning on covering any other cases in future podcasts? I really enjoyed Bone Valley and would love to hear more.

my questions about Leo's case:
- if Jeremy committed the murder as he describes it, how can the lack of blood in the vehicle be explained?
- if Jeremy broke into her car and stole her stereo, how can the locked car be explained? (I'm no expert but I can't imagine a thief locking up after themselves)
- if Michelle picked up Jeremy to give him a ride on her way home from work, how can the fact that her purse was found in her and Leo's home be explained?
- I know this is not really an answerable question, but in case you did learn anything about this, why was Leo's father not more thoroughly investigated considering his vehicle was seen both at his son's trailer the night of the murder and at the location of the victim's car after her disappearance? and then to just magically know where to find her body? Does Leo have any suspicions about his father's possible involvement?

36

lavaforgood OP t1_iwmb5s3 wrote

Many questions here, I will try my best to answer them all.
On the blood: So here’s what we know – a large quantity of Michelle Schofield’s blood was found in the dirt near the canal. Likely, the majority of the blood she lost. Looking at crime scene photos, it seems likely that this would’ve been right beside where the Mazda was parked. Gilbert and I really hate speculating about this publicly, but of course we’ve had these conversations privately. It’s definitely a valid question to wonder about the lack of blood in the Mazda. We’re not experts in forensics, so of course take this with a grain of salt, but our guess is that Jeremy threatened Michelle. This probably began in the car, but quickly moved outside of the vehicle. I believe (again, not an expert) it is possible the first stab could’ve happened within the Mazda, Michelle opened the door and got/fell out, and then the rest of the crime happened on the ground outside the vehicle, where most of her blood was found. This is primarily speculation, but it is of course based on our years-long, very thorough review of ALL the evidence, and of all of Jeremy Scott’s statements. I really hate speculating about the final moments of Michelle’s life, but I understand why it’s a lingering question.
On the car being locked: The car was not locked entirely, the hatchback was still unlocked when it was found. I don’t really have many other thoughts on this.
On Michelle’s purse: Michelle was known to carry money loose in her pocket, or use a money clip. The clerk at the gas station she stopped at the night she was killed distinctly remembers Michelle pulling out a money clip. Initially, Leo mentioned the purse to police because he thought it’d been stolen, before realizing it was still at home in their trailer.
On Leo’s father: It is our understanding that Leo Sr was thoroughly investigated, but the most damning evidence against him was just his weird statement about a vision. To clarify, these statements were made only after he found Michelle’s body. No one has ever claimed that Leo Sr told them about this vision before Michelle’s body had been found. We think it was his way of explaining the deeply traumatic experience of finding his daughter-in-law and the senseless crime she’d suffered. Mark McCoy on Twitter said, “an innocent man has been in jail for 30 years because his dad is the type of guy who says, ‘God helped me find my car keys.’” Gilbert and I couldn’t have said it better ourselves.
As for other cases, stay tuned!

- K.D.

45

RadioPodDude t1_iwolfp3 wrote

I wondered about some of the facts that weren’t more fully addressed in Bone Valley. Very impressed with these answers and your research and y’all’s reluctance to publicly speculate on the last moments of Michelle’s life. That’s what makes this podcast stand out. All the reporting choices you made. I hope Schofield does get his case before a less biased, less corrupt DA so that’s justice might prevail.

10

cvaldez74 t1_iwmpzgt wrote

Kelsey, GIRL. You are a QUEEN! Thank you for such well thought out and thorough answers. I’d writea longer response but I’m at a stop light lol…

9