Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

punkerster101 t1_isyrar1 wrote

Reply to comment by JayCroghan in IAmAn Irish guy who worked as an extra and got speaking parts in 3 Chinese blockbusters last year, Battle At Lake Changjin 1 & 2 and Wandering Earth 2! by JayCroghan

Interesting, howdy from Belfast, read your entire post it was good reading I don't really have a specific question but I found the entire thing very interesting thank you

10

JayCroghan OP t1_isyscho wrote

Thanks for reading, I'm glad you got something out of it.

5

DonaldTrumpTinyHands t1_it2bdph wrote

I'd be interested to hear from both of you in this thread. Firstly your lengthy post is quite remarkable for an AMA about a movie that wasn't really a hit outside of china, scored 5.4 out of 10 om IMDB and is largely viewed as propaganda with pro-china views and historical inaccuracies. Notwithstanding that the US has made similar propaganda movies such as Pearl Harbor. From a Chinese national point of view, knowing that the movie is historically inaccurate and largely ignored outside of china, what is it that appeals to you about this movie?

1