NegotiationSea7008 t1_j9f5uip wrote
Reply to comment by ImOnRedditMaaan in Would the most sentient ai ever actually experience emotion or does it just think it is? Is the thinking strong enough to effectively be emotion? by wonderingandthinking
Is the physical reaction necessary?
ImOnRedditMaaan t1_j9fgog3 wrote
youd have to define emotion at that point
NegotiationSea7008 t1_j9fn822 wrote
Tricky
Instinctive or intuitive feeling as distinguished from reasoning or knowledge.
Does that mean a feeling is instant and not a consequence of thought?
ImOnRedditMaaan t1_j9fsr1y wrote
do you get cold based on thinking your cold or the environment around you? is there a conscience connection between the feeling physiologically or just a natural physical reaction that gives the thought behind it. If the brain has to catch up to the physical feeling, if even a millisecond, the physical feeling existed before in this case which provoked the thought. but then what about a thought that provokes a physical feeling, kinda like anxiety. The thought was there but its only experienced because there is a physical feeling associated with it. so what is emotion then? if we look at common emotions we usually without thinking associate a physical aspect to it. Happy/Smile, Sad/Frown. So, the question is what is emotion and is there a physical relationship in its meaning? All things considered my answer is yes. But… but but… what about sensors? Could an AI experience a thought with an interpretation of a physical action? i think so. So in my opinion there has to be more to it than just “Can AI experience emotion?” A computer could not imo but a a computer with specific peripherals that could generate thought and have some sort of reaction physically could happen but AI would have to be very advanced at that point.
NegotiationSea7008 t1_j9g8uzf wrote
I would argue that feeling cold is a sensation rather than an emotion.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments