MudSling3r42069 t1_j250ryl wrote
Reply to comment by sky_blu in SpaceX launches 54 upgraded Starlink internet satellites and nails rocket landing at sea in 60th flight of the year by ovirt001
Other than the fact the ceo is eccentric and leads trust issues when it comes to contracts fast out blacking out Ukraine was questionable.
toastedcrumpets t1_j25g5n2 wrote
There were two parts to that Ukraine blacking out story. First was that they were charging for starlink after providing free initial access (terminals were bought by someone else). To be fair, this was clearly stated at the beginning, is normal capitalism, and the only reason the change was painful was because the service was so useful. This should have been a simple case of starlink's CEO saying someone has to pick up the tab but they'd offer it at cost, and it should have been a PR win.
The second was that starlink is blacked out in any areas under russian control, or being contested by Russia. This included the front lines for Ukraine which was a point of complaint. This is something outside starlink's control, embargoes against tech support of Russia are clear. You can bet the US government/military is telling starlink exactly when and where to enable it's service. For example, Starlink is active in Iran precisely to support US interests thanks to special exception even though this is illegal due to the overall sanctions in place.
All of this could have been handled by a competent PR department, but it's not something Elons companies have, deliberately so.
sky_blu t1_j2541s2 wrote
My assumptions are either
The public's idea of starlinks's involvement is Ukraine is not accurate (could be many reasons why)
My friends division has some very specific niche benefits from starlink that don't apply to Ukraine.
FeedMeACat t1_j25f0hs wrote
This is why the gov announced plans to build their own. Elon tried to price gouge when the service was critical and the military doesn't like that. They pay an extended helping hand back in contracts down the line. That is how they do things.
MightyMoonwalker t1_j25xwxn wrote
If the government builds their own, Elon Musk will still be the one getting rich building it and maintaining it. You think the owner of the only tech that could launch thousands of sattelites is bummed at the prospect of the government wanting to build something that requires thousands of sattelites?
AwesomeLowlander t1_j26ejh8 wrote
Looking at what the US govt spends in their space and military budgets... You really think they'll save any money by doing it themselves?
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments