slayemin t1_jbaxl31 wrote
Reply to comment by volci in A group of researchers has achieved a breakthrough in secure communications by developing an algorithm that conceals sensitive information so effectively that it is impossible to detect that anything has been hidden by thebelsnickle1991
What if they have a system which just runs an app that takes a picture with a phone and encodes the data in the least significant bits of the photo? If they can keep the LSB order random using an crytographically secure PRNG, it would be somewhat secure. The problem is, if an adversary believes a photo contains stego info, then it just becomes a crypto problem. Stego is just a form of security through obscurity, which generally isnt a good security policy.
ControlledSingular t1_jbbs43f wrote
Stego is usefull in a very different way from crypto. With crypto shure i might not know what you are sending between yourselves, but i can know that you are sending stuff. Thus if i catch one of you doing a crime for example, i will be very very interested in investigating your crypto communication buddies, even tho i do not know the messages themselves. Stego aims to fix this by hiding the fact you ever comunicated in the first place. This type of security is ONLY achievable by obscurity.
TheSoup05 t1_jbc7q7x wrote
LSB encoding using a PRNG order is a common way to do steganography, but it’s usually pretty easy to detect. Statistically, an image with LSB encoding will look different than one without it if you’re looking at the distribution of bits across the image.
The goal of the steganography isn’t to replace encryption though. For example, if Alice and Bob are criminals and Alice gets busted, it would definitely look suspicious if someone saw Alice sent Bob a bunch of encrypted messages. They might not be able to figure out what the messages contained, but they don’t need to know in order to start investigating Bob anyway.
Instead though, what if Alice just posted a picture to social media. Nothing about it looks weird, it’s just a regular social media post. Maybe the steganography is detectable if you’re already looking, but it isn’t weird enough to get someone to start looking at it on its own. But…Bob knows there’s a message encoded in that image and how to extract it. So Alice still gets caught eventually for some other reason, but there’s nothing actually connecting her to Bob. She didn’t send anything directly to him, it’s just an image that’s out there where anyone can see it. But Bob still got the message, and was the only one who did. Maybe the police go back now and analyze Alice’s pictures and see exactly which ones had a message encoded onto them, but they still can’t tell what the message was or who it was for.
Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments