Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

ThePresidentsNipples t1_ja8c7sk wrote

Reply to comment by FabioTheGeek in Shower valve versus handle replacement? by knewtoff

Be ready to replace the seats too (the part your cartridge butts up against in the back there)

22

knewtoff OP t1_ja8inyi wrote

Are those sold separately or in the same kit?

12

ThePresidentsNipples t1_ja8k00a wrote

I've never got them together myself, so I would assume not. Get a flashlight when you pull the cartridge and look for a seat. if there is one, look for wear and chipping. If its beat take it out by unscrewing it with a big flat head or two flatheads, or go get the tool specific for seat pulling(its cheap). Take that seat into your hardware store to compare it so you get the correct one..... looking closer at your pics, those definitely look old enough to have seats.

12

BYoungNY t1_ja9cxqz wrote

Fyi there's a seat removal tool that you need. Its usually square shaped and sold either at home Depot or Amazon for cheaper. You'll use it once every 10 years or so, so it's up to you weather it's worth the price or paying someone else. If you have an old diy'ee on your street I guarantee he'll not only let you borrow it, but be glad that it's getting some use.

10

fangelo2 t1_ja9qeib wrote

And you will never find it again when you need it. Possibly the day after you buy another one

13

WhyWouldYouBother t1_jaa6jms wrote

When you're putting away the new tool. Right where it logically should go.

9

Roundaboutsix t1_ja9aeiy wrote

Separate. Take the old cartridge with you. (I did this last week. My hardware store had the replacement washer for 19 cents.). If the cartridge is corroded/damaged, a new one should be available for less that $10. Replace or reuse the knob. (I wouldn’t worry too much about the seats. I’ve replaced several washers and cartridges and the seats have been fine.)

5

ltrain430 t1_jabg4yz wrote

I've done 3 and never replaced the seat either. I sold the house 4 years after replacing 2 so maybe they have issues now

1

eljefe512 t1_ja9guzr wrote

I literally bought two replacement stems yesterday from HD and the seats were included in the package.

4