Submitted by brettmancan t3_10ioxat in BuyItForLife

Hey folks, long time lurker of the bifl reddit community and long time advocate of all things bifl. My motto is "always buy quality" whenever it matters. That said, waffles are starting to make the list.

tl;dr: I need a waffle maker that will last, can make multiple waffles at once (at least 4, preferably more) and costs under $200. Quality matters too! Crispy outside is important. Prefer electronic over cast iron stove top model. Thank you!

Fun background/numbers stuff:

I have four kids and potentially more coming (plus sometimes they have friends over). We've started making waffle sandwiches and other waffle delights. We could easily go through two 24 boxes of eggos per month (we're currently over that amount right now). So naturally I calculated the payback period of a $50 waffle maker using a basic waffle recipe. Cost per eggo is just over $0.26 (in a 24 pack) and cost per waffle (depending on ingredients) is about $0.17. Assuming 50 waffles per month that puts me at an 8 month payback period. With a $200 waffle maker at 50 waffles per month it's a 2.9 year payback period. Considering the number of kids I have, the expected growth as they move into teen years and food consumption starts to get out of control, I think I need a waffle iron that makes at least 4 per round as a bare minimum. One waffle per 3-5 minutes isn't going to work when you're trying to feed a crowd. Ideally four waffles per three minutes would give me a dozen waffles in ten minutes - which is enough for now, but more is definitely better.
I did look at other postings on this but didn't see one that would work for us. A lot of vintage flairs out there and one suggestion for a $450 waffle maker that is out of budget.

Thanks for reading!

8

Comments

You must log in or register to comment.

MonkeyMom2 t1_j5fnq76 wrote

Make ahead and freeze. Toast as needed. Good project for kids with supervision.

I have a Waring Pro bought at Costco 15 years ago. Works a charm.

8

topcat5 t1_j5flin2 wrote

I would suggest looking around to see if you can find a used Carnival King. Or given what you said, biting the bullet and purchasing one new.

Keep in mind the amount of power you have available in your kitchen.

3

j_hoova6 t1_j5g6gfm wrote

We have a Waring Pro Double Belgian waffle maker. Granted, it only makes 2 at a time. We just throw them on a baking sheet in the oven as we make them (on low temp to keep them warm). Then everyone can still eat at the same time.

3

lil-smartie t1_j5fkckq wrote

We have a waring Pro that came back from the US to UK with us which is awesome! Bought from Sur la Table about 15yrs ago!

2

vieux_carre_nola t1_j5fueru wrote

Get ahold of a used FS Carbon Rugged I Belgian waffle maker. eBay will have them. It will outlive you. It’s only one at a time, but they separate into quarters.

1

idc69idc t1_j5g1m9e wrote

The answer is always restaurant supply stores, although your budget may not get bifl.

1

SeaworthinessAny3680 t1_j5hix70 wrote

I have the Breville, wanted one for years and pulled the trigger 2 years ago. Love everything about it

1

arafella t1_j5n17lk wrote

If you can stretch your budget to $220, the Breville 4-slice is legit. I think it's called a smart waffle, had mine about 4 years.

1