Viewing a single comment thread. View all comments

Dear_Noise_7588 t1_j2k4xe1 wrote

I think this is AI art because the arm goes in front of the cat then comes out behind it.

​

Edit : other perspective mistake : the fence on the right goes behind the back fence at the its top, and in front of it lower.

90

arandompurpose t1_j2kvoxb wrote

That was my first impression as well. A whole bunch of minor things that add up to it not looking fully right.

Edit: Did some quick digging and found a WIP so is hard to say.

35

Salvatio t1_j2m3e0o wrote

The top right part of the fence has a piece missing in the final version, but it's there in the WIP? This is so weird

3

jorppu t1_j2krkfx wrote

definitely AI, since an artist with skill to draw the subject matter would never settle for such an atrocious background and poor overall composition.

These AI bros can always make the AI take other artists skill and make a single subject look good, but they lack the eye for composition that comes with the craft.

18

azunaki t1_j2lnvj0 wrote

So now all artists are born with skill and none are learning and make mistakes?

Idk one way or the other, but obviously it's possible for someone that's still learning to draw to make mistakes, and not dissimilar to this.

13

ShinaS t1_j2lh7rz wrote

If you look at their twitter they have timelapse videos as well as work in progress pictures.

12

jorppu t1_j2lihtm wrote

One of the accounts posted here is suspended, which makes everything quite suspicious. They could still be using AI to paint over the sketch to compensate for their skill level, you never know.

Regardless even if it's not AI the criticism still stays true, since the background is still quite bad, as if it was traced over a photo blindly without regard for the overall composition, like an AI in a sense.

−3

Dash064 t1_j2kakj8 wrote

yea it looks funky. almost like they picked up a statue of a cat

7

someguyinadvertising t1_j2l5vsk wrote

Also the lack of response alongside every comment on the account posting for commission work lol

6

jammyartsit t1_j2myon1 wrote

It is devastating we're at a point where artistic touches classified as "imperfections" or refined details by the viewers are the deciding factors as to whether a piece is ai or not. This is definitely not ai, the artist uploads process videos on his Tik Tok, maybe next time just the constructive criticism?

4

Limp_Radio_9163 t1_j2n1jt4 wrote

I’ve done warped perspective(such as that fence)before on purpose, also the closer arm is going under the cats leg. But other than that yeah I see what you mean

1